Question:
Our firm is a four-lawyer estate planning firm in the Chicago suburbs with one owner and four associate attorneys. Our practices focuses on estate planning, estate administration, and elder law. Our estate planning work is handled on a flat fee basis and estate administration, and elder law is handled on time bill basis with retainer. Time sheets are recorded on both flat fee matters and time bill matters. Our flat fee rates and our hourly rates are in line with what other law firms in the area are charging. While the volume of our work can fluctuate at times overall it is generally stable. Since we keep timesheets on all of our work billable hours is one of our most important key performance indicators. Effective rates is another key indicator. Our associates have a billable hour expectation of 1400 annual billable hours and only one of our associates is even close to reaching 1400 hours. Effective rates are well below where they should be. Some are not even reaching 1200 hours. Some of the associates have the excuse that they don’t have enough work. I do not believe that this is the case. I would like to hear your thoughts on this matter.
Response:
This seems to be a common issue. Failure to attain billable hour goals can be caused by any one or a combination of the following:
- Work ethic and simply not working enough “worked hours.”
- Lack of work.
- Poor time management habits.
- Poor time keeping/recording habits.
I would start by observing the number of worked hours they are putting in. Are they putting in the hours? Observe as well as review their time reports – billable and non-billable time. If you do not track non-billable time start doing so. Then review and discuss with them their time management and time keeping/recording habits. Questions to ask include:
- Are they keeping time contemporaneously?
- Are they dropping time that is not getting into the system?
- Where is their time going?
- Are they being assigned non-billable work by others?
- Are they provided with proper staffing assistance?
Review and discuss workload levels of each associate and determine if lack of work is an issue.
I have found that often the cause of the problem is a combination of some or all four of the above listed causes. Lack of work is often one of the causes. My question to them would be:
- Have you advised anyone that you need work?
- What are you doing with your non-billable time if you do not have billable work?
The firm should have an established protocol for assignment of work to associates and to whom the associate advises that he or she needs more work. When billable work is slow and not available the associate should be assigned non-billable firm or business development projects such as developing document templates, writing articles, etc.
If the problem is work ethic appropriate consequences and disciplinary measures may be required.
If the problem is time management and time keeping training and habit building will be required.
Click here for our financial management topic blog
Click here for our profit improvement topic blog
Click here for articles on other topics
John W. Olmstead, MBA, Ph.D., CMC
The post Law Firm Profitability – Where are the Billable Hours? appeared first on Olmstead and Associates.
