When a pedestrian causes a car accident, they can actually be found legally liable for the crash. While drivers are typically expected to yield to pedestrians, the law does not automatically place all the blame on motorists. In Illinois, including Chicago, pedestrians are also required to follow traffic laws. If they act carelessly—such as jaywalking, stepping into traffic unexpectedly, or crossing against the light—they could be held partially or fully at fault. This means they may have to pay for damages and injuries caused by their actions.
At Phillips Law Offices in Chicago, we often see cases where pedestrians assume they are always protected by right-of-way laws. However, under Illinois law, fault depends on negligence, and pedestrians are not immune to accountability. Let’s take a detailed look at how liability is determined, what legal consequences may follow, and how insurance and compensation work in these situations.
Understanding Pedestrian Fault in Accidents
When Can a Pedestrian Be at Fault?
A pedestrian may be considered at fault when their behavior directly contributes to or causes an accident. For example, if someone jaywalks across a busy street, darts into moving traffic, or crosses against a red light, they are breaking traffic laws. Illinois Vehicle Code Section 11-1003.1 clearly states that both drivers and pedestrians must act with reasonable care to prevent accidents.
Imagine a pedestrian suddenly stepping into the road between parked cars where the driver has no chance to stop. If a crash occurs, the pedestrian’s action could be considered negligent. Similarly, walking along highways, being distracted by a phone, or ignoring pedestrian signals may all lead to shared fault under Illinois’ comparative negligence rule.
At Phillips Law Offices, our legal team helps evaluate these complex scenarios to determine how much blame, if any, belongs to the pedestrian.
Comparative Negligence in Illinois
How Shared Fault Works
Illinois follows the modified comparative negligence system. This means each party’s level of fault affects their ability to recover damages. If a pedestrian is found more than 50% responsible, they cannot collect compensation from others involved. However, if they are less than 50% at fault, they can still recover damages—though the amount will be reduced by their percentage of fault.
For example, if a pedestrian was jaywalking but the driver was speeding, a court might assign 30% fault to the pedestrian and 70% to the driver. In that case, the pedestrian could still recover 70% of the total damages.
This system ensures fairness by recognizing that accidents often involve shared responsibility. A skilled Chicago personal injury lawyer from Phillips Law Offices can carefully assess the evidence to protect the pedestrian’s rights or defend a driver wrongly accused of full fault.
Examples of Pedestrian Negligence
Common Scenarios Where Pedestrians Cause Accidents
Several actions can lead to a pedestrian being found responsible for a crash, such as:
- Crossing Outside a Crosswalk: When pedestrians cross mid-block or outside a designated area, drivers may not have enough time to stop.
- Ignoring Traffic Signals: Walking when the “Don’t Walk” sign is flashing is considered a direct violation of traffic rules.
- Sudden Entry into Traffic: Stepping into the road without checking for vehicles can lead to rear-end collisions or swerving accidents.
- Walking While Distracted: Using a smartphone, listening to music with headphones, or being intoxicated while crossing the street can all contribute to accidents.
Each of these behaviors shows a lack of reasonable care, which forms the basis of negligence in Illinois law.
Can Drivers Sue Pedestrians for Damages?
Yes. If a pedestrian’s actions lead to an accident, the driver has the right to file a claim for property damage, medical bills, or lost wages. For instance, if a driver swerves to avoid a pedestrian who ran into the street and ends up hitting another car or a pole, the pedestrian can be held financially responsible.
However, these cases can be difficult to prove without strong evidence. At Phillips Law Offices, we help clients gather critical proof, such as surveillance footage, witness statements, and police reports, to demonstrate fault clearly. Our attorneys also work with accident reconstruction experts who can establish how the pedestrian’s negligence triggered the event.
Police Reports and Determining Fault
How Authorities Assess Responsibility
After a pedestrian-involved crash, police officers will investigate the scene to determine who was at fault. They will document evidence, take statements, and note any traffic violations. If the pedestrian violated Illinois traffic law—such as crossing illegally or being under the influence—it will be included in the official report, which is often used later in insurance or court proceedings.
Still, even if the report indicates pedestrian fault, insurance companies may try to dispute it. That’s why having a personal injury attorney in Chicago is crucial to ensure that the legal record accurately reflects the facts and that your rights are protected.
Insurance Coverage for Pedestrian-Caused Accidents
Who Pays for the Damages?
If a pedestrian causes an accident, determining which insurance policy applies can be confusing. Usually:
- Pedestrian’s Homeowner’s or Renter’s Insurance may cover damages if they were negligent.
- Driver’s Auto Insurance might cover damages initially, but the insurer could later seek reimbursement from the pedestrian.
- Personal Injury Protection (PIP) or Medical Payments Coverage may pay for immediate medical care regardless of fault.
When disputes arise, the lawyers at Phillips Law Offices work directly with insurance companies to negotiate fair settlements and ensure clients are not unfairly burdened with costs caused by someone else’s carelessness.
What If Both the Pedestrian and Driver Are Injured?
Accidents involving pedestrians often leave both parties hurt, and the question of fault becomes even more critical. If the pedestrian is partly to blame, they might receive reduced compensation. However, if the driver was texting, speeding, or driving under the influence, they could still bear the majority of the responsibility.
In these cases, attorneys evaluate medical records, eyewitness accounts, traffic camera footage, and police findings to establish each party’s role. The legal team at Phillips Law Offices in Chicago often helps clients recover compensation for medical expenses, lost income, pain, and suffering—even when fault is shared.
Legal Consequences for Pedestrians at Fault
Can Pedestrians Face Legal Penalties?
Yes, pedestrians who break traffic laws may face citations or fines, just like drivers. If their negligence causes serious injury or death, they could even face civil lawsuits or criminal charges for reckless endangerment.
Beyond financial liability, these incidents can have long-term legal consequences. Having experienced representation ensures that your case is handled properly, whether you are the injured driver or the accused pedestrian.
How Phillips Law Offices Can Help
At Phillips Law Offices, our Chicago-based attorneys have decades of experience handling pedestrian accident cases—on both sides of the issue. We carefully review every detail, from police reports to insurance policies, to build the strongest possible case for our clients.
We aim to secure maximum compensation for accident victims and defend individuals unfairly blamed. Whether you’re a pedestrian injured in a crash or a driver seeking justice for damages caused by reckless behavior, our legal team provides dedicated, results-driven representation throughout Illinois.
What to Do After an Accident Involving a Pedestrian
- Call the Police Immediately – Report the accident and wait for officers to arrive.
- Seek Medical Attention – Even minor injuries should be checked by a doctor.
- Collect Evidence – Take photos, get witness contact information, and record details of the scene.
- Avoid Admitting Fault – Wait until speaking with an attorney before giving statements.
- Contact a Lawyer – The experienced team at Phillips Law Offices can help protect your rights from the beginning.
Need Legal Help After a Pedestrian Accident? Contact Phillips Law Offices Today
If you’ve been involved in an accident where a pedestrian caused or contributed to the crash, don’t try to handle it alone. The laws in Illinois can be confusing, and insurance companies may not always treat you fairly. The experienced pedestrian accident lawyers at Phillips Law Offices in Chicago can help you understand your rights, prove who was at fault, and fight for the compensation you deserve.
Call Phillips Law Offices today for a free consultation and get the trusted legal support you need to move forward with confidence.
Interesting Reads:
When Is a Pedestrian at Fault for a Car Accident?
How Long Does It Take to Settle a Pedestrian Accident?
What Type of Lawyer Deals With Pedestrian Accident Injuries?
The post What Happens If a Pedestrian Caused an Accident? appeared first on Phillips Law Offices.