Sometimes a pedestrian slips, trips, or falls because of an irregularity in a sidewalk or other paved area. In many cases, a fall causes little more than embarrassment and spilled shopping bags, but what if a sidewalk slip-and-fall causes a serious injury requiring medical treatment? Before filing a claim for your injury-related damages, it’s important to understand the De Minimis rule.
A court ruling in Illinois states the following about a plaintiff in a sidewalk injury claim:
“…She sustained “severe and permanent” injuries from falling on an uneven spatial gap in a City sidewalk. The trial court entered summary judgment in favor of defendant on the ground that the defect in the sidewalk was de minimis.”
“De minimis” is a Latin term meaning “of minimal importance.”
What Does De Minimis Mean In Sidewalk Injury Claims?
In other words, the injury victim (plaintiff) in the above case did not win because the sidewalk defect was minor, and the court found it unreasonable to expect property owners and city agencies to maintain a sidewalk, walkway, or paved surface in perfect condition. Most courts define de minimis sidewalk defects as cracks, gaps, and uneven sections of less than two inches.
While the de minimis rule can be a significant obstacle in sidewalk injury claims in cases of small defects and irregularities, an experienced personal injury lawyer can often make a strong case proving liability.
What If a Small Crack or Defect In a Sidewalk Caused My Fall and Serious Injury
The de minimis rule presumes that even a reasonably prudent property owner might not notice or promptly repair a minor defect in a sidewalk, walkway, or other paved area. Despite the de minimis rule, it’s still possible to recover compensation for injury damages, such as medical expenses, lost wages, and compensation for pain and suffering. Some common rebuttals to the de miminis rule for sidewalk slip-and-fall injuries include the following:
- Other factors contributed to the fall, such as inadequate lighting, flashing signs, litter, or other distractions and obscuring effects contributed to the fall, and the property owner or city entity could have corrected the contributing factors
- The property owner failed to clear snow, ice, or fallen leaves that hid the crack or uneven pavement from view
- The de minimis rule should not apply in your situation due to heavy foot traffic in the area increasing the duty of care to address any slip-and-fall or trip-and-fall danger, regardless of the size
- Asserting the importance of details other than the size of the defect, such as crumbling debris surrounding a small crack, sharp edges that can catch on clothing, or photos and videos showing the defect from multiple angles to demonstrate how it could present a clear danger
- Showing that the sidewalk or other paved area does not meet building code requirements or requirements for the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA)
Finally, a history of prior complaints, repair requests, or previous injuries can show the de minimis rule doesn’t apply because the property owner and/or city agency knew of the dangerous condition and failed to report, repair, or correct it.
An experienced sidewalk slip-and-fall accident attorney also consults with experts, including safety engineers and medical expert witnesses, to prove how the injury occurred and seek the full extent of the injury victim’s damages under the modified comparative negligence law in Illinois.
{
“@context”: “https://schema.org”,
“@type”: “BlogPosting”,
“headline”: “What Is the “De Minimis” Rule In Illinois?”,
“author”: {
“@type”: “Person”,
“name”: “Legal Team”
},
“publisher”: {
“@type”: “Organization”,
“name”: “Smith LaCien”,
“url”: “https://www.smithlacien.com”
},
“description”: “Sometimes a pedestrian slips, trips, or falls because of an irregularity in a sidewalk or other paved area.”
}
{
“@context”: “https://schema.org”,
“@type”: “FAQPage”,
“mainEntity”: [
{
“@type”: “Question”,
“name”: “What Does De Minimis Mean In Sidewalk Injury Claims?”,
“acceptedAnswer”: {
“@type”: “Answer”,
“text”: “In other words, the injury victim (plaintiff) in the above case did not win because the sidewalk defect was minor, and the court found it unreasonable to expect property owners and city agencies to maintain a sidewalk, walkway, or paved surface in perfect condition. Most courts define de minimis sidewalk defects as cracks, gaps, and uneven sections of less than two inches. While the de minimis rule can be a significant obstacle in sidewalk injury claims in cases of small defects and irregularities, an experienced personal injury lawyer can often make a strong case proving liability.”
}
}
]
}
