Libation Law Blog

Alcoholic Beverage and Cannabis Regulatory and Legal Updates

Latest from Libation Law Blog - Page 2

A “100% agave” label tells buyers something about how their tequila was made. Does Mexico’s certification prevent an American court from examining whether that representation is true? The dismissal of the Costco tequila lawsuit gives certification that effect. But, respectfully, the court likely got this wrong.

In Salisbury v. Costco Wholesale Corp., No. C25-2277-KKE (W.D. Wash. Oct. 16, 2026), the Judge dismissed claims challenging Kirkland tequila’s “100% de Agave” labeling. The order finds “dismissal with prejudice is warranted under both the international comity and act of state doctrines.” Those grounds ended the case without resolving the competing scientific claims…
Continue Reading Costco’s Tequila Win: Why “100% Agave” Should Remain a Testable Claim

Buy the domain before you file the trademark application or announce the beverage brand. Otherwise, your competitor might acquire it, redirect visitors to its own website, and answer your request for its return with “We will offer it to you for $1 B” and a laughing emoji. That happened in the BuzzBallz–Big Sipz fight. The web addresses eventually changed hands for free; the embarrassment earned a permanent place in a federal court opinion. (Order, pp. 3–5.)

“$1 B ” — BuzzBallz’s joking response after Big Sipz discovered that its competitor had acquired its domain name. The exchange appears…
Continue Reading BuzzBallz v. Big Sipz: Buy the Domain Before Your Competitor Does

Beer Wolf looks like the eighties forgot to close their tab. The bandana. The women in bikinis. The unmistakable air of a creature who would explain your own drink to you, then ask whether your boyfriend was around. You can practically smell the tanning oil and the motel bar carpet. Bringing him back to sell T-shirts was a choice. Giving him a federal court docket really completed the comeback.

Why revive this guy? Let him run wild. Somewhere, a beach bar still has a wet T-shirt contest and a malfunctioning ice machine. First, a few exhibits from his advertising career.
Continue Reading Beer Wolf Trademark Lawsuit:A Licensing Deal Bites Back

A beer distribution agreement can promise a 30-day exit without supplying a lawful basis for termination and the whole mechanism and contract can get written in blatant contravention of a state’s beer franchise laws. A recent Florida beer distributor termination dispute shows why brewers and wholesalers should read the franchise statute alongside the contract, and why their lawyers should do the same before sending termination notices or briefing their rights to do so.

In Titan Products of Puerto Rico Corp. v. Compañía Cervecera de Puerto Rico, Inc., Judge Julie S. Sneed denied both sides’ summary-judgment motions on October 15,…
Continue Reading Before a Brewer Terminates: Lessons from Titan’s Florida Franchise Fight

Retailer returns could turn Illinois’ November 12 hemp deadline into a warehouse problem for beverage distributors. A store sends back unsold THC drinks, the distributor issues a credit, and the cases wait for the supplier’s truck. If that truck arrives after the deadline, the distributor may have cleared the retailer’s account while keeping the regulatory problem.

The Illinois Department of Revenue’s new hemp bulletin, announced October 14, gives suppliers and wholesalers a reason to settle those arrangements now. IDOR confirms that Illinois plans to begin enforcement on November 12 “regardless of the federal government’s delay of related enforcement.” The…
Continue Reading Illinois’ Hemp Deadline: Don’t Let Retailer Returns Become Your Warehouse Problem

Coors Distributing Company’s Colorado fight with Crown Imports and Constellation shows how a termination-payment clause can help a supplier argue for ending distribution before an arbitrator decides whether the exit violates the law. Our earlier post challenged the suppliers’ reading of Colorado’s 90-day termination provision. The new injunction briefing highlights risks in beer distributor termination provisions. We examine those risks and offer our own sample contract language addressing buyout payments and preserving distributors’ remedies.

What the New Coors Filings Reveal

Crown and Constellation filed their opposition on October 2. At the October 14 hearing, Denver District Judge Adam J. Espinosa…
Continue Reading Coors’ Colorado Fight: What Beer Distributors Should Fix Before a Supplier Leaves

When we wrote about the Sixth Circuit’s cannabis contract decision last month, the concern was what the decision allowed a buyer to accomplish: enter a licensed commercial transaction, abandon its purchase commitment when the market turned, and then invoke federal marijuana law to avoid liability for the breach. Hello Farms has now asked the court to reconsider, and its petition develops several of the same objections we raised about contract avoidance, federal policy, and the incentive to move these disputes into federal court.

The October 8 petition seeks both panel rehearing and rehearing en banc in Hello Farms Licensing …
Continue Reading Hello Farms Seeks Rehearing Over the Sixth Circuit’s Cannabis Contract Escape Route

“100% agave” and “handcrafted” help explain why a tequila costs more. They also give plaintiffs something specific to challenge when laboratory testing or production records appear to contradict the label. The recent 818 tequila ruling suggests that these claims could fuel another wave of the consumer-expectation litigation familiar from “natural” food labeling disputes. Suppliers and wholesalers should pay attention to how their bottles, websites, and sales materials describe both ingredients and production.

The controversy already extends across brands and jurisdictions. Reuters reported the May 2025 suit involving Casamigos and Don Julio, followed by reporting on similar cases in California …
Continue Reading What Tequila Brands Should Learn From the 818 Labeling Lawsuit

When a legislature defines a word, courts should start with that definition. Justice Nicholas Bronni followed that approach in Arkansas’s Kirkland Signature distribution dispute, and his dissent got it right. The majority’s contrary reading allows one producer’s wholesaler appointment to control other producers’ distribution choices simply because their products share a name – even if that name is a private label. Suppliers and wholesalers now must plan around that holding, despite its flawed reasoning.

In Arkansas Wine & Spirits Wholesale, LLC v. Arkansas Department of Finance & Administration, 2026 Ark. 137 (Oct. 8, 2026), suppliers of Kirkland Chianti and…
Continue Reading Before You Sign a Distribution Deal: Lessons from Arkansas’s Kirkland Signature Wine Case

Beverage cold storage clauses should do more than name a temperature. They should assign responsibility, preserve evidence and explain who pays when the cold chain fails. Nic’s Beverages learned how expensive the missing pieces can become.

In Nic’s Beverages, LLC v. Waco Bottling LLC, a Texas appellate court affirmed no-evidence summary judgment on a supplier’s contract and negligence claims involving two shipments totaling 80,000 pounds of CBD-infused cold brew. The court identified delivery-trailer ambient readings of 69°F and 80°F—not proven bottle temperatures. Its central observation: “NB presents no evidence that the product itself ever exceeded the required temperature or…
Continue Reading Beverage Cold Storage Clauses: Protect the Product—and the Proof

A failed software upgrade, 200,000 undelivered cases of alcohol, and a federal court decision that could change how retailers approach control-state distribution contracts.

Mississippi restaurants and liquor stores spent much of early 2026 confronting a problem that no retailer should face: they ordered alcohol, paid for it, and then waited weeks for deliveries that never arrived. And because Mississippi operates a control-state distribution system, retailers couldn’t simply call another wholesaler.

The problems reportedly began when Ruan Transport Corporation, the private company operating Mississippi’s sole state liquor warehouse, implemented new warehouse management software. According to the allegations, the software couldn’t…
Continue Reading When the State’s Liquor Warehouse Fails, Can Retailers Sue? A Mississippi Court Says Yes.

An agency should not escape an otherwise valid negligence claim merely by sending a letter announcing its mistake. Yet a recent TTB permit termination dispute pushes federal immunity in that direction, treating restrictions on a distillery’s approval access as part of the government’s misinformation rather than separate conduct. For suppliers and wholesalers, that distinction could determine whether a damages claim reaches the merits. 

Red Boot Distillery’s TTB permit dispute

In JDSO, Inc. v. United States, No. 4:25-cv-00444-SHL-SBJ (S.D. Iowa July 24, 2026), Red Boot Distillery alleged that TTB overlooked ownership documents submitted during an earlier permit amendment. Almost three…
Continue Reading TTB Gets the Permit Wrong—and the Distillery Pays the Price

Part 2 of 2: The price-discrimination settlement.

A wholesaler’s price book can show the same offer to every customer while rebates, credits, and qualification rules deliver a very different deal. Southern Glazer’s FTC complaint and the newly issued proposed settlement give wholesalers a reason to examine that gap—not to abandon legitimate discounts, but to understand who can obtain them and what supports the resulting price differences. 

Part 1 of our two-part series on these SG issues followed marketing money into personal benefits concealed behind false invoices. The FTC’s separate December 2024 lawsuit instead challenged allegedly discriminatory pricing that disadvantaged…
Continue Reading Same Bottle, Different Deal: What Southern Glazer’s FTC Settlement Means for Wholesalers

Part 1 of 2: The non-prosecution agreement.

A supplier’s approval of a marketing billback does not tell a wholesaler whether the event happened, who actually benefited, or where unused money went. Southern Glazer’s non-prosecution agreement shows how certain employees, supplier representatives and vendors exploited those gaps to turn promotional spending into personal benefits. For other wholesalers, the agreement offers something more useful than a collection of embarrassing anecdotes: specific practices to recognize and weaknesses to test in their own operations. 

On September 10, 2026, Southern agreed to pay $12.5 million and undertake compliance and cooperation obligations to resolve a…
Continue Reading Marketing Billbacks and Dirty Tricks: What Wholesalers Should Learn from Southern Glazer’s NPA

What good is a statutory right to cure a breach if a supplier can bypass it simply by waiting another thirty days? Coors Distributing’s lawsuits against Crown/Constellation and Mark Anthony Brands bring that question into focus. CDC alleges the suppliers are ending decades-long relationships without cause and seeks injunctions while the disputes proceed toward arbitration. Law 360 and Beer Business Daily have both covered the facts. But wholesalers in Colorado and around the country cannot afford to ignore the rationale and silliness behind the supplier argument that Colorado created an exception to franchise protections that destroys all value if a…
Continue Reading Can a Beer Supplier Take Decades of Goodwill for Free? Coors’ 90-Day Fight