Blog Authors

Latest from Chicago Criminal Law Blog

Texas Set to Execute Man Based on Disproven “Shaken Baby Syndrome” Theory
Next month, Robert Roberson is scheduled to be executed in Texas based on his conviction for killing his 2-year-old daughter in 2002 after medical experts testified at his trial that the combination of injuries found on her body could only have been caused by violent shaking, or the well-known theory of shaken baby syndrome (“SBS”). Roberson’s defense stated his daughter was sick, evident in the fact that he had taken her to the doctor twice in the past week after she ran a high fever and had been
Continue Reading Junk Science Remains a Problem in Criminal Courts

Appellate Court Decision Provides Pathway for High Court Review
We have previously covered that the United States Supreme Court has consistently declined to intervene and hear the current challenge to the Illinois state law that bans AR-15s which was passed in wake of the Highland Park July 4th shooting, but it appears that there is now an avenue for the Supreme Court to rule on similar bans in the near future. Although the Supreme Court said that the Second Amendment guarantees an individuals right to use a weapon for self-defense, the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals recently upheld a Maryland
Continue Reading Could Supreme Court Weigh in on AR-15 Bans in the Near Future?

FDA Gives Early-Stage Approval for Psychedelic Used to Treat Mental Health Issues
Psychedelics are enjoying a surge of interest from pharmaceutical companies looking to explore their potential for treatment of several mental health issues, from addiction to PTSD. Although the Food and Drug Administration (“FDA”) recently rejected one company’s proposed treatment, as we covered here, that does not mean it’s the end of the road for the industry on the whole, which has invested heavily in the psychedelic space. Recently, the FDA approved an early-stage clinical trial of the psychedelic compound known as “Moxy” to treat depression, anxiety, post-traumatic
Continue Reading FDA Approves Clinical Trial for AI Discovered Psychedelic

Federal Judge Rules Public Transportation Gun Ban Unconstitutional
As we have previously covered, there has been a flurry of litigation when it comes to Illinois’ gun laws at both the state and federal level, as advocates on both sides of the issue continue to push their own respective agendas. Recently, a federal judge in the Northern District of Illinois ruled in Schoenthal v. Raoul, that the state law that bans anyone, including those that are licensed concealed carry (“CCL”) holders, from bringing their firearms onto public transportation is a violation of the Second Amendment right to defend themselves. The
Continue Reading Gun Regulation in Illinois Continues to Grab Headlines

CTA Using Artificial Intelligence Surveillance Program to Identify Guns in Stations
Earlier this month the Chicago Transit Authority (“CTA”) announced that it was currently one month into a year long pilot program with the private company ZeroEyes, a company that pairs surveillance videos with artificial intelligence to detect firearms. As implemented as part of the pilot program, when the AI technology software detects a possible firearm, a human employee is then alerted who reviews the footage for accuracy before they then alert the Chicago Police Department, the CTA and the Office of Emergency Management and Communications at the same time.
Continue Reading Illinois Government Agencies Use of Controversial AI Technology

Concerns of Police Overstepping When Collecting DNA Samples Post Arrest
Since the Supreme Court ruled in 2013 that law enforcement can take DNA samples from arrestees after an arrest is not a violation of an individual’s Fourth Amendment rights. the practice has become routine in many states, but some question whether law enforcement is crossing an ethical boundary in the widespread practice. Currently 30 states collect DNA from anyone arrested for a felony, with 8 of those states expanding the practice to specific misdemeanor arrests. Many in law enforcement point to highly publicized cases in which DNA profiles have helped
Continue Reading Post-Arrest Swabs Are Legal But Are They Justified?

Investigation Finds Chicago Police Officers Routinely Fail to Report Traffic Stops
A recent investigation by a watchdog organization found that Chicago Police officers have routinely failed to document instances of traffic stops that do not end in arrest or charges, as many as 20,000 a month last year, in violation of a 2003 law which mandates that every traffic stop must be documented. This information stands in stark contrast to CPD Superintendent Larry Snelling reporting this past June that traffic stops in Chicago were down by approximately 87,000 stops from last year. What is particularly troubling about these numbers is
Continue Reading Illinois Police Departments Show Troubling Patterns in Use of Traffic Stops

Concerns Raised Over Federal Law Enforcement Agencies Buying Peoples’ Data
It is becoming increasingly apparent that the government may be circumventing the Fourth Amendment protections against unreasonable searches by buying up large amount of data from third parties that collect information about a person’s location via their cellphone data. While the Supreme Court ruled that the government must have a warrant to access historical cell site location information and track people’s movements through cell phones in Carpenter v. United States, this hasn’t stopped federal law enforcement agencies from simply buying data in bulk from third parties when trying to investigate
Continue Reading Federal Government May Be Violating Your Fourth Amendment Rights

Indiana Woman Sentenced to 4 Years in Prison for Role In Death
Ashantae Corruthers, an Indianapolis woman, was the second person sentenced to federal prison for their role in procuring a firearm for a known felon by acting as a “straw purchaser” for a person who was legally prohibited from owning a firearm that would ultimately kill a police officer with the weapon. As we have previously covered, a straw purchaser of a firearm is someone who falsely certifies on a form used by the United States Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosive (“ATF”) that they are purchasing a
Continue Reading Straw Purchaser of Gun Used in Police Officer’s Death Sentenced

Company Hopes It Can Convince FDA to Reevaluate Drug as Treatment for PTSD in Future
The US Food and Drug Administration recently rejected a company’s proposed treatment for PTSD which would have prescribed the drug MDMA combined with talk therapy for federal approval, instead requesting “an additional Phase 3 trial to further study the safety and efficacy” of the proposed treatment. We have previously covered that there is a growing movement advocating for the use of psychedelics such as psilocybin and others as possible therapy drugs for patients, and this rejection is another sign of the legal roadblocks that the
Continue Reading FDA Rejects Approval for MDMA Therapy

DOJ Sets Procedures for Federal Agencies to Interact with Social Media Companies
The Department of Justice (“DOJ”) recently announced that it had developed and implemented formal policies and procedures for how the FBI and other federal agencies should interact with social media companies to try and ensure that the government is not infringing on First Amendment rights of individuals. This comes after growing concerns that the government agencies may be engaging in “jawboning,” which is the practice of the government indirectly censoring free speech illegally through coercing private companies to do it for them. Although Mark Zuckerberg had revealed to
Continue Reading Growing Concerns Over Social Media and Government Agencies

Calls for Specific Guidelines Enhancements for Crimes Utilizing Artificial Intelligence
As we have previously covered, the Department of Justice (“DOJ”) remains focused on the impact that Artificial Intelligence (“AI”) could/does have on criminal activities and continues to evolve its policies surrounding the new technology. In a recent report to the United States Sentencing Commission, an independent agency of the judiciary that develops the federal sentencing guidelines, the Criminal Division of the DOJ recommended that the guidelines be altered to include sentencing enhancements that would explicitly target those that use AI technology in the commission of their crimes. They argue
Continue Reading Department of Justice Wants Increased Punishments for Crimes Involving Artificial Intelligence (AI)

Bills Aimed at Public Safety and Transparency Fail to Garner Support for Vote
Three proposed bills aimed at preventing gun violence and increasing transparency and accessibility for the public of police activity failed to receive a vote this past spring session despite being introduced at the start of the year. Those bills were known as Karina’s Bill, the Homicide Victims’ Families’ Rights Act, and the Homicide Data Transparency Act. Karina’s Bill, named after Karina Gonzalez and her 15-year-old daughter who were murdered by their husband/father when they had an active order of protection against him, would both clarify the process
Continue Reading Illinois Legislature Declines to Vote on Gun Safety Laws as Crime Rates Rise in Chicago

New York Judge Finds Search of Individual’s Locked Phone at Border Crossing Violates Fourth Amendment Rights
Judge Nina R. Morrison, a federal judge in New York, ruled that US Customs agents are not permitted to force a traveler to unlock their phone in order to search the contents of said device without a warrant. The case that brought the issue to the judge’s attention revolved around Kurbonali Sultanov, a naturalized US citizen from Uzbekistan, who was ordered by Custom and Border Protection (CBP) officers to hand over his phone and unlock it when he attempted to re-enter the United States
Continue Reading Increased Scrutiny Over Warrantless Searches of Phones at the Border

Department of Justice Continues Crackdown on Sinaloa Cartel with Arrest of El-Chapo’s Son 
As we have previously covered, the DOJ has continued its pursuit of those connected to fentanyl distribution and specifically the Sinaloa drug cartel by recently announcing the arrest of two alleged high ranking officials in the organization, including the son of the infamous founder of the organization “El Chapo” Guzman who is currently serving a life sentence in the United States in connection with his running of the cartel. In announcing the charges, the prosecution highlighted the drug organizations role in distributing multiple drugs in
Continue Reading DOJ Remains Focused on Prosecuting Fentanyl Distributors and Producers

Senator Bob Menendez Found Guilty on All Counts in Jury Trial
New Jersey Senator Bob Menendez was found guilty by a jury of 16 felony charges relating to a complex scheme to accept bribes in exchange for helping various individuals and two foreign governments in his capacity as a sitting United States senator. We’ve previously covered the Senator in a different alleged bribery scheme after the Senator’s then trial resulted in a hung jury before prosecutors eventually dropped the charges in 2018 rather than retry him. In his conviction in the most recent matter, Senator Menendez is now the first
Continue Reading United States Senator Convicted in Bribery Trial