After more than 40 years handling car accident cases in Illinois, I have seen a major change in how evidence is collected. It used to be that cases were built on police reports, witness statements, and medical records. Today, social media plays a much bigger role. What you share online can seriously affect your injury claim, even when you think it is private or harmless.
Many people underestimate how much insurance companies and defense lawyers investigate online activity. I have seen clients lose credibility or reduce their potential settlement because of something as simple as a photo on Facebook or a post about “feeling better.” What you say and post online can easily be misinterpreted and used against you.
If you were involved in a car accident in Chicago, understanding how social media can impact your case can help you protect yourself from mistakes that might hurt your recovery.
(For a complete overview of what to do after a collision, visit our Chicago car accident lawyer guide.)
Insurance Companies Monitor Social Media Closely
Insurance companies use social media more than ever before. They search public accounts to find anything that might reduce your claim value. They are not looking for the truth; they are looking for evidence that can be spun to weaken your case.
Here are some examples of what insurance investigators look for:
- Photos or videos that show physical activity or smiling with friends
- Check-ins or tagged locations that suggest travel or recreation
- Comments about your accident or injuries
- Posts made by friends or family members mentioning your recovery
- Public online fundraising pages or reviews referencing your accident
Even something innocent can be taken out of context. A single picture at a family event might be used to claim that your injuries are minor.
How Harmless Posts Can Be Misinterpreted
A few years ago, I represented a client who suffered serious back injuries in a rear-end crash. She later attended a wedding and took one group photo while standing. The defense team presented that single image to the jury to argue that she had recovered. What the photo did not show was that she spent most of the evening sitting and in pain.
That experience reminded me how easily social media can be twisted. Once a photo or post is online, you cannot control how others interpret it.
Avoid Deleting Posts Without Legal Guidance
Deleting your posts might seem like a smart move, but it can actually make things worse. When you delete social media content after an accident, the defense might accuse you of destroying potential evidence. This is called “spoliation,” and courts take it seriously.
The safest approach is to stop posting altogether and talk to your attorney before making any changes to your online accounts. Your lawyer can help you decide what is appropriate to keep private and how to preserve your current content without risking penalties.
Practical Tips for Protecting Your Case Online
Here are some steps I recommend to every client as soon as we begin working together:
- Stop posting on all platforms. Do not share updates, photos, or opinions about your accident.
- Switch your accounts to private. Limit who can see your information, but remember that nothing is ever completely private online.
- Do not discuss your case. Avoid mentioning your injuries, doctor visits, or conversations with your lawyer.
- Ask friends and family not to tag you or post about you. Their posts can still be found by insurance companies.
- Keep screenshots of your profiles. This shows you are not deleting or hiding anything.
- Do not comment on public pages related to your accident. Even innocent remarks can be taken out of context later.
These small actions can make a big difference in how smoothly your claim proceeds.
Your Online Activity Extends Beyond Social Media
Insurance investigators also look at other digital sources, not just social media. They sometimes review:
- Data from fitness apps such as Fitbit or Strava
- Google reviews or public comments mentioning your accident
- Job listings or online resumes suggesting physical activity
- Dating profiles that describe you as “athletic” or “very active”
Even small details can be twisted into arguments that you are not as injured as you claim. I have seen defense lawyers use minor inconsistencies to cast doubt on otherwise strong cases.
When Social Media Evidence Helps Your Case
There are situations where online content can actually strengthen your claim. For example, if the other driver posted photos of reckless driving, alcohol use, or speeding before the crash, that can support your case.
Our firm has used this type of evidence successfully, especially in cases involving commercial drivers or rideshare operators. If your accident involved Uber or Lyft, you can learn more about how their insurance policies work on our rideshare accident.
When used correctly, social media can expose negligence and help establish liability. The key is knowing how to collect and present that information lawfully.
Your Digital Footprint Matters
In today’s world, your online presence is part of your case whether you realize it or not. Once a personal injury claim begins, assume that everything on the internet could appear in court. This is not about hiding information; it is about protecting your credibility.
At Phillips Law Offices, we guide clients through every step of the process, including how to manage their digital activity. We know how insurance companies build their cases, and we know how to protect your interests from being undermined by online evidence.
If you have been injured in a car accident, talk to a car accident attorney in Chicago before posting anything online. We can help you avoid mistakes and ensure your case remains strong from start to finish.
Call (312) 346-4262
161 N Clark St, Suite 4925, Chicago, IL
Free Consultation | No Fee Unless You Win
The post How Social Media and Online Activity Can Impact Your Car Accident Case appeared first on Phillips Law Offices.